Milwaukee Brewers: Two Crucial Losses And Two Unnecessary Departures For 2024

Luna Greco

5 min read

Post on Apr 23, 2025

4.9

Share

The Crucial Losses: Impacting the Brewers' Core

The Brewers suffered two devastating losses this offseason, significantly impacting their core strength and potential for a playoff run. These departures leave considerable gaps in key positions and present significant challenges for the team's management.

Loss of Corbin Burnes: A Hole in the Starting Rotation

• Key Statistics (2023): Corbin Burnes posted a 10-8 record with a 3.32 ERA, showcasing his continued pitching prowess, though slightly lower than previous years. He remained a valuable asset in the rotation.
• Role within the Team's Strategy: Burnes was a cornerstone of the Brewers' pitching staff, consistently providing quality starts and anchoring the rotation. His presence provided stability and confidence to the entire team.
• Difficulty of Replacing His Skill Set: Replacing Burnes' high-quality pitching, especially his ability to consistently pitch deep into games, will be extremely difficult. His command and arsenal of pitches are not easily replicated.
• Potential Internal Replacements and Their Limitations: While the Brewers have promising young pitchers in their farm system, none possess Burnes' experience and proven major league success. Promoting from within risks inexperience and inconsistencies.
• Options in Free Agency or Trades: The Brewers will need to aggressively pursue free agent pitchers or explore trades to fill this significant void. This will likely require a significant financial commitment or trading valuable prospects.

The Departure of Willy Adames: A Blow to Shortstop

• Contributions to the Team: Willy Adames provided consistent offense and strong defense at shortstop, a critical position in baseball. His leadership and clubhouse presence were also valuable assets.
• Unexpected Nature of Departure: Adames' departure, whether via trade or free agency, was unexpected and leaves a significant hole in the infield. His departure represents a major loss of experience and leadership.
• Impact on Team Chemistry and Morale: Losing a key player like Adames can negatively impact team chemistry and morale. The Brewers need to address this aspect proactively.
• Implications for Depth at Shortstop: The Brewers lack a clear and ready replacement at shortstop internally. Finding a suitable replacement is a critical priority.
• Potential Replacements and Challenges: The Brewers will likely need to explore free agency or trades to find a suitable replacement, considering both offensive and defensive capabilities.

Unnecessary Departures: Questionable Roster Decisions

Beyond the crucial losses, the Brewers also made some questionable roster decisions that raise concerns about their strategic direction heading into the 2024 season.

Release of [Player C's Name]: A Surprising Move (Example: Eric Lauer)

• Circumstances Surrounding Release: (Example: Eric Lauer's release, if it happened, might be due to salary concerns or a shift in team strategy). The Brewers might have decided to prioritize younger, cheaper options.
• Potential Reasons Behind the Decision: (Example: Budgetary constraints, a desire to give younger pitchers opportunities, a disagreement on contract terms.)
• Impact on the Team's Overall Depth: Releasing a veteran pitcher like Lauer diminishes the depth of the pitching staff, making them more vulnerable to injuries.
• Potential Cost Savings and Risks: While releasing Lauer might save money, it increases the risk of insufficient pitching depth during the season.
• Alternative Solutions Considered: The Brewers might have considered alternative solutions, such as renegotiating Lauer's contract or exploring trades before ultimately releasing him.

Trade of [Player D's Name]: A Risky Gamble? (Example: Keston Hiura)

• Details of the Trade Involving Player D: (Example: A trade sending Hiura to another team for a lower-level prospect might have been viewed as necessary to clear space for other players.)
• Return the Brewers Received: The return in a trade involving a player like Hiura would need to be carefully evaluated for its potential to contribute to the team's future.
• Value Lost in Trading Player D: Trading away a player with potential, even if inconsistent, represents a gamble. The Brewers will need to see strong performance from the acquired assets to justify the move.
• Potential Long-Term Implications: The long-term implications depend on the performance of the received prospects and how the Brewers manage the loss of Hiura's potential contributions.
• Necessary Move for the Brewers' Future: The decision to trade Hiura needs to be viewed within the context of the Brewers' overall rebuild strategy.

Conclusion

The Milwaukee Brewers' offseason moves have left the team with significant holes to fill. The loss of Corbin Burnes and Willy Adames represents a blow to the team's core, while the departures of players like Eric Lauer (example) and Keston Hiura (example) raise questions about the team's strategic direction and risk assessment. These roster decisions will significantly impact the Brewers' performance in the 2024 season.

Call to Action: What are your thoughts on the Brewers' offseason moves? Do you think they've made the right choices to contend in 2024? Share your opinions and analysis in the comments below! Let's discuss the future of the Milwaukee Brewers and how they can overcome these challenges to return to the playoffs in 2024. #Brewers #MLB #OffseasonMoves #2024Season #BrewersBaseball #MilwaukeeBrewers