Trump's Economic Agenda: Winners And Losers

Luna Greco

5 min read

Post on Apr 22, 2025

4.3

Share

Tax Cuts and Their Impact

The cornerstone of Trump's economic policy was the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, a significant overhaul of the US tax code. This legislation dramatically altered the tax landscape, resulting in both significant benefits and considerable criticisms.

Beneficiaries of the Tax Cuts

The most significant beneficiaries of the tax cuts were corporations and high-income earners.

• Increased Corporate Profits: Lower corporate tax rates (reduced from 35% to 21%) led to a surge in corporate profits, boosting shareholder returns and executive compensation. Many companies used the savings for stock buybacks rather than investment in job creation or wages.
• Shareholder Dividends: Increased corporate profitability translated into higher dividends for shareholders, primarily benefiting wealthy individuals who hold significant stock portfolios.
• Reduced Tax Burden for the Wealthy: The tax cuts also significantly reduced the tax burden for high-income individuals, particularly those in the top 1%. This resulted in increased disposable income for this demographic.

While proponents argued this would stimulate economic growth through investment, critics pointed to the long-term consequences, including a ballooning national debt and increased income inequality. The Congressional Budget Office estimated that the tax cuts would add trillions to the national debt over the next decade.

Those Left Behind by Tax Cuts

The benefits of the tax cuts were far less pronounced for lower and middle-income earners.

• Minimal Tax Relief: Many lower and middle-income families saw minimal tax relief, despite the tax cuts being marketed as beneficial for all Americans. The tax benefits were largely concentrated at the top of the income distribution.
• Increased Inequality: The disproportionate benefits of the tax cuts exacerbated existing income inequality, widening the gap between the rich and the poor. This increased inequality had cascading effects on various aspects of society, including access to healthcare, education and housing.
• Stagnant Wages for Some: Despite claims of increased job growth, wage growth for many workers remained stagnant, failing to keep pace with inflation. This indicated that the tax cuts did not translate into widespread improvements in the standard of living for a large segment of the population.

The tax cuts' regressive nature—benefiting the wealthy more than the poor—sparked significant debate about their overall impact on economic fairness and social mobility.

Trade Policies and Their Effects

Trump's administration implemented a protectionist trade policy characterized by tariffs and trade wars, significantly impacting various sectors of the economy.

Winners from Trade Protectionism (Tariffs)

Certain industries benefited from Trump's tariffs, primarily those involved in steel and aluminum production.

• Increased Domestic Production in Certain Sectors: Tariffs on imported steel and aluminum temporarily boosted domestic production in those industries, protecting some American jobs.
• Potential Job Creation (with caveats): While some job creation occurred in these sectors, it was often offset by job losses in other industries negatively affected by retaliatory tariffs and reduced exports. The net effect on job creation remains debated.

It's crucial to note that these gains often came at the cost of higher prices for consumers, who ultimately bore the burden of the tariffs through increased costs for goods.

Losers from Trade Wars

Many industries suffered significant losses due to Trump's trade wars, particularly those heavily reliant on international trade.

• Increased Costs for Businesses: Tariffs increased the cost of imported goods for businesses, raising production costs and squeezing profit margins.
• Job Losses in Export-Oriented Sectors: Retaliatory tariffs imposed by other countries harmed American businesses that exported goods, resulting in significant job losses in various sectors.
• Retaliatory Tariffs from Other Countries: The trade wars led to a tit-for-tat escalation of tariffs, harming both American exporters and importers. For example, the agricultural sector suffered significantly from retaliatory tariffs imposed by China.

The overall impact of Trump's trade policies was complex and multifaceted, with winners and losers across different sectors and regions.

Deregulation and its Consequences

Trump's administration pursued a policy of deregulation across numerous sectors, aiming to reduce government oversight and promote economic growth.

Industries that Benefited from Deregulation

Several industries, including finance and energy, benefited from reduced regulations.

• Reduced Compliance Costs: Less stringent regulations lowered compliance costs for businesses, leading to increased profits in the short term.
• Increased Profits: Reduced regulatory burdens potentially spurred greater investment and increased profits in some sectors.
• Potential for Increased Investment: The easing of regulations could, theoretically, encourage greater investment in some industries.

However, this deregulation often came at a potential cost to environmental protection and consumer safety.

Negative Impacts of Deregulation

The consequences of deregulation extended beyond immediate economic gains, often affecting environmental protection, worker safety, and consumer protection.

• Increased Pollution: Reduced environmental regulations led to increased pollution in some areas, negatively impacting public health and the environment.
• Weakened Worker Protections: Reduced labor regulations potentially weakened worker protections, increasing risks for employees and lowering wages in some sectors.
• Increased Risk of Financial Crises: Relaxing financial regulations increased the risk of future financial crises, as seen in the 2008 financial crisis which was partially attributed to lax regulation.

Conclusion

Trump's economic agenda had a profound and complex impact on the American economy, creating both winners and losers. While corporations and high-income earners largely benefited from tax cuts, many lower and middle-income individuals saw limited gains. Similarly, while some industries benefited from protectionist trade policies and deregulation, others suffered significant job losses and increased costs. The long-term consequences of these policies, including increased national debt and environmental damage, continue to be debated and analyzed. Understanding the intricacies of Trump's economic agenda is essential for informed discussions about the future of the American economy. Continue your research and engage in informed conversations about the lasting effects of these policies on the winners and losers of Trump's economic agenda.